I was disappointed when AT&T changed it's policy not to offer an upgrade without additional fees when the iPhone5 came out. This is the first time they are enforcing this policy. I've had all the iPhone versions and they've always offered to upgrade free. I guess that I will just let my contract run it's course and switch to another carrier. Maybe it's time to look at an android phone for a change. I'll still keep my iPhone and use it as an iTouch.